Chapter 3: What Renzo Never Said

Théo Marchetti had not planned on staying the night in Solvane Hollow. He hadn't planned on staying past the reading, if he was honest — he'd told his assistant back in the city to keep his calendar clear for exactly two days, a funeral and a will reading, in and out, back to a life he'd built specifically so he'd never have to sit in a room that smelled like his childhood for longer than necessary. Instead he was sitting in his mother's kitchen at eleven at night, still in his funeral clothes, listening to his father pace. "Absolutely not," Renzo said, for what might have been the twentieth time. "I won't have my son extorted into marriage by a dead man's grudge." "It's not a grudge, Renzo, it's an olive branch shaped like a legal document," Camille said, from the table, where she'd been sitting very still for most of the last hour, her hands wrapped around a mug of tea she wasn't drinking. "Alden loved this valley more than he loved being right. You know that. You've always known that, you just can't say it because it would mean admitting your own father might have been the one who couldn't let it go." Renzo stopped pacing. "Careful." "I've been careful for thirty years," Camille said, and something in her voice made Théo look up. "I watched my husband and my father-in-law and Alden Halloway waste sixty combined years of a friendship none of them will explain to me, over something I have genuinely never once heard a straight answer about, and now the man who at least had the decency to try to fix it is dead, and you're standing in my kitchen still defending the wound instead of the cure." Théo had rarely heard his mother speak like that. Camille Marchetti's currency was warmth, was smoothing things over, was the quiet competence of a woman who'd spent three decades absorbing the tension between her husband and his family so her son wouldn't have to carry it. He realized, watching her now, exactly how much it had cost her to keep doing that for so long, and felt something in his chest twist with a guilt he'd been outrunning for a decade. "I'm not marrying a stranger because Grandpa wanted a fairy tale ending," Théo said finally, into the pause. It came out sharper than he meant it, the old reflex, charm as a shield except there was no room to charm anyone here, not with his mother's eyes on him, tired and hopeful in a way that hurt worse than his father's anger. "I know," Camille said. "I'm not asking you to do it for a fairy tale." She turned the mug slowly on the table, not looking at either of them now. "I'm asking you to do it because if we don't, we lose the land within six months, and I will watch your father lose the only thing that's ever made him feel like he mattered, and I don't think either of us will survive watching that happen to him twice." "Camille," Renzo said, low. "It's true and you know it's true." She looked up, finally, at her son. "Théo. I'm not going to pretend this is fair. It isn't fair. You left because this place asked too much of you and gave too little back, and I never once blamed you for going, because I watched what it did to your father and I understood. But I'm asking you to come back for one year, not for the vineyard, not for your grandfather, not even for me. I'm asking you because I think, somewhere under everything you've built to protect yourself from this family, you still love this land exactly as much as I do, and I think you know it, and I think that's the real reason you're standing in this kitchen at eleven at night instead of already on a plane." Théo didn't have an answer for that, because she was right, and he hated that she was right. "And the girl," Renzo muttered. "The Halloway girl." "Wren," Théo said, before he'd decided to correct him, which surprised even him. "Her name's Wren." His father looked at him with an expression Théo couldn't read. "You remember her." "Barely." A lie, or close enough to one. He remembered exactly one thing about Wren Halloway with any real clarity — a barn cat stuck in a fence at the harvest festival when he was maybe nine, her voice sharp and furious at the boys who'd been laughing instead of helping, the way she'd knelt in the dirt in her festival dress without a second's hesitation. He'd freed the cat because she'd shamed him into it, and then he'd walked away without a word because his grandfather Nico had been watching from across the field with an expression that made it clear exactly what would happen if his grandson was seen being friendly with a Halloway. He'd thought about that cat, and that girl, more times over the years than he'd ever admitted to anyone, a small persistent splinter of a memory from before he'd learned to want nothing this place could give him. Today, across the aisle at the reading, she'd looked at him like she was doing the same math he was — cold, fast, furious, and underneath it, something that wasn't quite despair. He'd said something glib because that was the only gear he had left by that point in the day, and she hadn't laughed, and he'd respected that more than he expected to. "I need to think," he said, which was true, and also a way of ending the conversation before his mother's hope wore any more visible cracks into her face. He went out to the porch alone. The Marchetti house sat higher on the slope than the Halloway place, close enough that on clear nights you could see their porch light from here, a small gold coin of light across the dividing line neither family had ever managed to fully close. He'd spent a childhood staring at that light and being told, in a hundred small unspoken ways, that the people who lived under it were the enemy, without ever once being told why. He pulled out his phone and, on impulse he didn't examine too closely, searched Wren Halloway's name. Not much came up beyond the estate's own site — a photo of her at a harvest gala three years back, unsmiling in the particular way of someone who'd rather be doing literally anything else, a brief mention in a regional wine journal calling her "one of the valley's most exacting young palates," a wedding announcement from eight years ago he had to scroll past fast, followed six years later by a divorce filing that was public record and none of his business, and yet he lingered on the date anyway, doing math he had no right to do. She'd been left, he realized. Not the leaver. The left. He thought about what it would take to walk into a marriage with a woman who already knew, in her bones, exactly how easily a person could decide she wasn't worth staying for — and what kind of contract, what kind of careful legal language, could possibly make that safe for either of them. He thought about his mother's face. He thought about the barn cat. He thought, against every instinct he'd spent a decade building, about the specific fury in Wren Halloway's eyes across that aisle, which had looked less like a woman trapped and more like a woman calculating exactly how she was going to survive this on her own terms. He went back inside and found his mother still at the table, his father gone up to bed, the kitchen quiet around her like a held breath. "I'll go talk to her," he said. "Just talk. No promises." Camille's face did something complicated — relief, and grief, and something that looked almost like pride — and she reached up and squeezed his hand once, hard, the way she used to when he was small and scared of something he wouldn't name. "That's all I'm asking," she said. "Just talk to her." It wasn't, of course, all either of them was asking. But it was enough, for tonight, to get him back to Solvane Hollow in the morning, standing at the edge of Halloway land for the first time in ten years, working up the nerve to knock. He didn't sleep much. He lay in his childhood bedroom, unchanged in a decade except for a fresh coat of paint his mother had insisted on before he left for the city — the same narrow bed, the same window facing east toward the ridge, the same crack in the plaster near the closet he used to trace with his finger as a boy, lying awake and furious at a fight he didn't understand and wasn't allowed to ask about. He thought about the version of himself who'd slept in this room at seventeen, already counting down the days until graduation, already certain that leaving was the only way to become a person instead of a extension of his father's grievances. He thought about how strange it was to be back in that same bed, thirty-two years old, about to consider marrying a stranger for reasons that had nothing to do with the life he'd built specifically to avoid this exact fate. Around two in the morning he gave up on sleep entirely and went down to the kitchen, where he found his mother still awake too, sitting at the table with an old photo album open in front of her, one he recognized instantly — decades of harvest photographs, Marchetti crews going back generations, his grandfather Nico young and laughing in half of them. "Couldn't sleep either," Camille said, not looking up. "No." He sat down across from her, glancing at the album. "What are you looking for?" "I don't know, exactly. Some proof, maybe, that this family was happy once. Before all of it got so complicated." She turned a page, landing on a photograph of a much younger Nico standing beside a man Théo recognized with a jolt — Alden Halloway, both of them grinning, arms around each other's shoulders, sleeves rolled up, clearly mid-harvest, clearly, unmistakably, friends. "I found this a few years ago, going through your grandfather's things after he had his first stroke. I never showed your father. I didn't know what to do with it — the two of them looking so plainly happy together, when everything I'd ever been told about their history was bitterness and betrayal. It didn't match. I've never been able to make it match." Théo studied the photograph a long moment, something in his chest tightening at the easy warmth so visible between the two old men, decades before either of them became the bitter, silent figures he'd grown up half-fearing. "Maybe it never was betrayal," he said slowly. "Maybe it was something smaller and stupider that just got allowed to grow, because nobody ever forced it back down to its actual size." "Maybe," Camille agreed, closing the album gently. "I hope you and Wren get the chance to find out, if you do this. I think this family's owed an answer, after sixty years of living inside a story nobody actually understands." Théo didn't respond to that directly, but he carried the photograph's image with him up the stairs when he finally went back to bed — two young men, arms around each other, grinning at a camera that had captured a happiness neither of them, apparently, had ever managed to hold onto — and he fell asleep, finally, sometime near dawn, with the strange, unfamiliar hope that whatever he was about to walk into might, somehow, be a chance to reclaim something that had been lost long before he was ever born.

Before you start reading

You must be 18 or older

Comments (0)